Restaurants in Mansfield, Ohio - Wishmaker Houses

The best restaurants in Mansfield, Ohio

Our favorite places to eat near Mansfield

It’s hard to believe that we’ve lived in Mansfield for almost 5 years! Time has flown by! Mansfield is home to many kid-friendly attractions and is famous for being the filming location of The Shawshank Redemption, but it’s also the place to find many great restaurants. We never run out of places to eat in Richland County! Today I’m sharing a few of our favorite places to eat in Mansfield.

Best restaurants in Mansfield, Ohio

Rancho Fiesta

Rancho Fiesta is an unassuming, but extremely popular Mexican restaurant between Lexington and Mansfield. This casual dining experience in a themed restaurant is perfect for those who love Mexican but don’t want to spend a fortune. Have a pick of your favorites like tacos, enchiladas, or chimichangas, and then wash it down with a cold Corona. Rancho Fiesta is a local favorite, and deservingly so.

Outdoor patio dining is offered during warm weather.

Restaurants in Mansfield Ohio- Rancho Fiesta

Rancho Fiesta is located at 1360 S Trimble Rd, Mansfield.

Reindeer Grill

Reindeer Grill is located on the south side of the square in downtown Mansfield and offers affordable lunch and dinner entrees in a family-friendly environment. Ralph and Lisa Powell relocated the thriving take-out business they owned in Maryland and chose Mansfield as the place to raise their family.

I don’t think there is a bad meal on the menu, but our family favorites are the pizza, garlic knots, and the Philly Mac & Cheese (what can I say, we like carbs)! Chef Ralph makes his own pizza dough and sauce in-house- and that’s what makes it so amazing. Check out their website for the full menu.

The Reindeer Grill is located at 10 S. Park St., Mansfield.

Reindeer Grill Mansfield Ohio- best places to eat in Mansfield Ohio
Try the pizza at the Reindeer Grill!

Uncle John’s Place

Uncle John’s is a place that the locals visit for burgers and a beer. This lunch hotspot is also located near the square in downtown Mansfield. Uncle John’s is open every day but Sunday.

Visit Uncle John’s Place is 18 S. Main Street, Mansfield.

1285 Winery

1285 Winery is the restaurant attached to the Blueberry Patch. 1285 Winery is one of our favorite Mansfield restaurants for a date night – its beautiful new building and patio has quite the romantic vibe. The restaurant serves up wood-fired pizzas and signature entrees, along with their famous dry or sweet blueberry wine. Just want apps and drinks? We loved the baked brie (smothered in their blueberries and local maple syrup) and the pretzels with beer cheese.

1285 Winery is located at 1285 W Hanley Rd, Mansfield.

1285 winery- Mansfield ohio restaurants- places to eat in Mansfield, Ohio

Places to eat in Bellville, Ohio

Wishmaker House

Do you like wine and cheesecake? Do you wish you had the ability to dine outdoors year-round? The Wishmaker House is the place for outdoor dining even in the winter months because they offer igloo seating on their large patio. The dreamy igloos have space heaters to keep you toasty and are decorated seasonally to set the ambiance. For a perfect holiday evening, dine in one of the igloos and then set out on a tour of Christmas lights in the Mansfield area.

Wishmaker House Bellville - best places to eat in Mansfield, Ohio
Wintertime at Wishmaker House means dining in an igloo

The patio is also a beautiful spot in the summer dining al fresco, (sans igloos), entertained by local musicians and shaded by large trees. If it’s too muggy in mid-Ohio summer, Wishmaker House has indoor seating, too!

Wishmaker House offers a seasonal menu that includes salads, flatbread pizzas, and craft brews. Check out their website or Facebook page for more information.

The Wismasker House is located at 116 Main Street, Bellville, Ohio.

Brumby’s Coffeehouse and Pizzeria

Brumby’s is an eclectic mix of a coffee shop and pizza joint! This Bellville restaurant in an idyllic historic building on Main Street Bellville is the place to bring friends for a casual evening.

Tip: Take time before dark to take a photo with the mural on the side of the building. 😉

Brumby’s Coffeehouse and Pizzeria is located at 96 Main Street, Bellville.

Fast Eddie’s Pizza

Fast Eddie’s Pizza is one of the most popular pizza restaurants in the Mansfield area. Serving up great pizzas, appetizers, and beer; Fast Eddie’s is usually hopping with business during the dinnertime hours.

The restaurant offers indoor and outdoor dining, but it’s not a huge establishment and seating can be limited. On a warm day it may be nice to get a pizza to-go and eat at Charles Palm Park. See my list of the best parks in Mansfield here.

Fast Eddie’s Pizza is located at 59 Main St, Bellville.

Black Dog Tavern

Black Dog Tavern is the restaurant within the clubhouse at Deer Ridge Golf Course. Being on the golf course means that the view from the deck is absolutely stunning in the summer and early fall, and it’s fun (and sometimes funny) to watch people tee off.

Black Dog Tavern- best places to eat in Mansfield, Ohio
You must try the Buckeye Pie at Black Dog Tavern on the grounds of Deer Ridge Golf Course

The indoor clubhouse has a cabin feel and a huge bar! The restaurant is open year-round and is very close to the hotel waterpark Splash Harbor.

Black Dog Tavern is located at 900 Comfort Plaza Dr, Bellville, Ohio.

Places to eat in Lexington, Ohio

Tito’s Cantina & Grill

Tito’s is an upscale Mexican eatery with a trendy bar located in Lexington. This is the place to go if you’re craving amazing guacamole or flavorful street tacos. Reservations are accepted.

Tito’s is closed on Sundays and Mondays. Check their website for their menu and online ordering.

The Cantina is located at 320 1/2 E Main St, Lexington.

Tito's Cantina and Grill in Lexington Ohio - best places to eat in Mansfield Ohio - restaurants in Mansfield Ohio
Korean taco and a giant enchilada at Tito’s Cantina & Grill

The Happy Grape Bar & Bistro

The Happy Grape Bar & Bistro is a casual dining experience serving flatbreads, sandwiches, and more. Not only does The Happy Grape features great wine flights like “Shawshank Redeemed,” it is also home to Laxton Hollow Brewing Works, the only English Cask Ale Brewery in Ohio.

The Happy Grape Bar is located at 300 E. Main Street, Lexington. Check their Facebook page, as hours change seasonally.

Our favorite bakeries in Mansfield, Ohio

Buckeye Bakery

Buckeye Bakery is a local favorite for donuts, cakes, and cookies. Located in downtown Mansfield near the Carrousel and Little Buckeye Children’s Museum. Take out only.

Buckeye Bakery is located at 21 E 4th St, Mansfield.

Share ‘N Dippity

Share ‘N Dippity is a French bakery located in residential part of Mansfield. This hidden gem is the place to please your palate on scones, muffins, breads, quiches, macarons, and more. There is a small dine-in area, or carry-out to enjoy later.

Share N Dippity is located at 287 Taylor Rd, Mansfield.

Apple Hill Orchards

Apple Hill Orchards is a family-owned orchard that grows over 30 varieties of apples and other fruits. However, I’d say that most of the locals visit for the fresh-made apple donuts or apple cider. Stop in for local maple syrup, fresh veggies, and local meats, but most of all- don’t forget the donuts. You’re welcome. 😉

Apple Hill Orchards is located at 1175 Lexington-Ontario Rd. This is really close to the Ohio Bird Sanctuary (OBS is on my list of the best things to do in Mansfield with kids) and makes an easy stop for a snack.

Blueberry Patch

The Blueberry Patch is one of Ohio’s premier blueberry growers and is the place to purchase fresh blueberries in season (late July). But while I do enjoy their blueberries, the sweet goodness they create in blueberry donuts is pretty exceptional.

I hope my list of restaurants in Mansfield, Ohio has helped you narrow down the choices for your next date night or group outing. What is your favorite place to eat in Mansfield? Maybe I’m forgetting one I can add to the list!


Restaurants in Mansfield, Ohio - the best places to eat in Mansfield.
(Visited 2,152 times, 59 visits today)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top